Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 42

Thread: Lochte scratches 200 Free

  1. #1
    Very Active Member
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Posts
    584

    Lochte scratches 200 Free

    Saving up for the 100 Back - did enough for the relay ...

  2. #2
    Very Active Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Location
    Texas
    Posts
    7,697
    Blog Entries
    1178

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    good strategy
    he needs to rest up for the 100 bk
    to improve his chances of making top 2 and making the medley relay
    it'll be a dog fight all the way

    larsen jensen's lucky day
    8 JENSEN Larsen TROJCA 1 SEP 1985 1:47.08

  3. #3
    Very Active Member
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Posts
    119

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    wait, is the 4x200 relay made up based on times or top 6 in finals? some combination of both?

  4. #4
    Very Active Member Sam Perry's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2003
    Location
    Scottsdale, AZ.
    Posts
    647

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    Quote Originally Posted by cowsvils View Post
    wait, is the 4x200 relay made up based on times or top 6 in finals? some combination of both?
    Top 2 are on for sure, then coaches discretion. His time last night pretty much assures him a spot in the relay. The 100 Back will be the race of the night, if not the meet. The 1-4 spots are a complete tossup. It will be awesome!
    These amino acids are awesome, now I need a new Speedo.

  5. #5
    Very Active Member
    Join Date
    May 2003
    Location
    Houston
    Posts
    1,122

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    The men's 800 free relay is going to be really really fast. They are going to go below 7:00 in 5 weeks!

    I am glad that Lochte went ahead and gave the coaches the proof that they need to put him on the relay in Beijing. Clearly he deserves a spot on the relay. He probably would have been on the relay anyhow, but now we won't have a repeat of the minor Phelps/Hall controversy from Athens.

    The 100 back will be great. My bet is the first titan will go down and Piersol doesn't make the team in this event.

  6. #6
    Just swim. USMSarah's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2003
    Location
    USA
    Posts
    736

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    Quote Originally Posted by lefty View Post
    The 100 back will be great. My bet is the first titan will go down and Piersol doesn't make the team in this event.
    I don't know about Piersol. I am rooting for him, though. He did have a good semi swim. Did I hear correctly that he is not shaved? However, it's going to be one heck of a race no matter who wins.

  7. #7
    Very Active Member Chris Stevenson's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    Richmond, VA
    Posts
    3,947
    Blog Entries
    1217

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    Quote Originally Posted by USMSarah View Post
    I don't know about Piersol. I am rooting for him, though. He did have a good semi swim. Did I hear correctly that he is not shaved? However, it's going to be one heck of a race no matter who wins.
    If I understood the interview correctly, he didn't shave for prelims and clipped for semis. Certainly he will shave for finals, way too competitive to do otherwise.

    Regardless who wins, there will be some long faces after the race. What a brutal meet.

  8. #8
    Very Active Member knelson's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2003
    Location
    Seattle, WA
    Posts
    7,212
    Blog Entries
    526

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    It should be a dogfight between Peirsol, Bal, Grevers and Lochte. I was actually wondering if Lochte might go for the 200 free. Things might have been different had the 100 back final been first on tonight's schedule.

  9. #9
    Very Active Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Location
    Texas
    Posts
    7,697
    Blog Entries
    1178

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    Olympic Relays

    top 6 in the 100 & 200 freestyle go to the Olympics
    the idea is 4 relay members and 2 alternates are eligible to make the olympic team, the Olympic Committee has a selection proceedure document,
    where they place priorities, 26 men and 26 women can make the team
    With Phelps and Lochte making multiple events they won't be close to 26 mens members.

    That's why making to 6 in the 200 free tonight is critical

    I believe Michael PHELPS and Peter VANDERKAAY, will be first and second, Klete could step up and pop a great one.

    That leaves Dave WALTERS, Ricky BERENS, Danny BEAL, Larsen JENSEN, and Erik VENDT fighting for the next 3 spots, who ever is 7th and 8th won't be on the Olympic Team for the 4 x 200 relay
    But remember Larsen Jensen is already on the Olympic Team for the 400 fr, if he has an amazing 200 free in practice at the Olympics they'll consider using him.

    At the Olympics there's a prelim swim and final swim, anyone who swims in prelims earns the medal if one is won in finals.

    Olympic coaches test the swimmers in practice and see how well they swim their events at the Olympics.

    On Relay Day:
    Prelims:
    4 swimmers will be chosen to swim prelims, maybe the 4 slowest, USA has the luxury of swimming the 4 slowest and still making top 8,
    their instructions will be
    SAFE STARTS and
    swim as fast as you can.
    The fastest swimmers don't have to swim in the morning so they can get extra rest.
    Usually you see 4 swim the morning
    2 rest
    then the 2 fastest from the morning swim at night along with the 2 very fastest who didn't swim in the morning

    at this olympics we might see 4 swim in the morning then 4 different swimmers swim at night,

    BUT coaches will pick the 4 fastest swimmers to swim in finals,
    whether they were top 6 or not, Lochte is going to let his 1:45.6 time stand.

    The controversy in 2004 was Michael Phelps didn't swim the 100 free at trials but he had a faster 100 free time. Gary Hall was very vocal that Phelps shouldn't be on the final relay. Eddie said the fastest swimmers swim at night, Gary had a time to beat and didn't.

    My guess is phelps will swim the 100 free prelims and post a fast 100 time then drop the semis and finals

    going into 2008 trials before the LZR I believed in the 100 free
    it was going to take a 48.6 - 48.7 to make the US Olympic team, I now think top 6 will be in the range of 48.2 - 48.5 and top 2 should be under 48


    Quote Originally Posted by cowsvils View Post
    wait, is the 4x200 relay made up based on times or top 6 in finals? some combination of both?
    Last edited by ande; July 1st, 2008 at 03:37 PM.

  10. #10
    Very Active Member
    Join Date
    May 2003
    Location
    Houston
    Posts
    1,122

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    Quote Originally Posted by ande View Post
    Olympic Relays
    But remember Larsen Jensen is already on the Olympic Team for the 400 fr, if he has an amazing 200 free in practice at the Olympics they'll consider using him.
    I don't think attempting this is even an option for him. IF he goes a 4:41 in the 400 he might be able to convince someone to atleast give him a shot in a time-trial, but considering that he has tonights competition to prove he deserves the spot this has got to be his only chance. If I was the coach and he told me that he wanted to time trial to earn a spot on the relay, I would ask him why he has been training for the 200 when the US needs him to swim well in the 1500 and 400.

    SO who will be the odd guys out? I think Jensen and Beal.

  11. #11
    Very Active Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2002
    Location
    West Bloomfield, MI
    Posts
    1,186

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    Quote Originally Posted by Sam Perry View Post
    Top 2 are on for sure, then coaches discretion. His time last night pretty much assures him a spot in the relay. The 100 Back will be the race of the night, if not the meet. The 1-4 spots are a complete tossup. It will be awesome!
    The Top 2 are not necessarily on for sure. John Piersma won the 200 Free at the 1996 Olympic Trials and beat Josh Davis (1:48.97 to 1:49.29) and they were the two selected to represent the USA in the 200 Free. Piersma swam a poor swim in the prelims of 1:50.XX and was not even selected to swim the prelims of the 800 Free Relay to be given another chance to prove himself. It probably mattered that he swam a poor 400 Free in the prelims and the coaches decided to swim others swimmers that made the top 6.

    Another example of this is Lindsay Benko who was second in the 200 Free at the 2004 Olympic Trials but did not swim as fast in the heats of the 200 Free in the Olympics in Athens. Because the coaches thought she didn't swim as fast as expected in the individual event, she swam the prelims to prove that she could swim as fast as the trials swim. It didn't happen and she was off the final of the 800 Free Relay.

    In 1996, Jenny Thompson was 7th in the 200 Free at Olympic Trials and did not qualify to swim in the relay per top 6 rule. The coaches can over rule that if they feel the relay would be faster with another swimmer on it. Jenny didn't even swim prelims and swam on the gold medal winning relay in the finals. In 2000, she didn't even swim the individual event at Olympic Trials but swam in the finals on the gold medal winning relay.

    These decisions by coaches are not without controversey. I remember reading something about Christina Teutcher in 2000. She swam the 200 Free in the Olympic Trials and had a time that was faster than the others that were sent to swim the relay. She was told she did not have to swim the prelims to prove that she could swim the time that was done in the Olympic Trials and it would be best to rest up for the 200 IM individual event, which she took a bronze medal. As the story goes she found out 10 minutes before the 800 Free Relay final started that she would not be swimming the relay. She let her emotions speak in an interview with Swimming World about 6 months after the Olympics.
    Skip Thompson

  12. #12
    Very Active Member
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Austin, TX
    Posts
    1,047

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    Frank - I thought the controversy in 2004 with the women's 800 involved Rachael Komisarsz? Natalie Coughlin's book describes the controversy but does not name the swimmer who didn't get to swim finals. The book describes a very vocal negative reaction to the coaches decision.

    In 2004 there was another controversy - the men's 4x100 free. Crocker swam leadoff and swam poorly. He had a fever for several days. He deserved to be on the relay based on time but Eddie misjudged Crocker's ability at the time. The relay finished 3rd, unable to recover from the poor 1st leg. Crocker recovered to swim superbly on the medley relay after Phelps stepped aside.
    From the Rolling Stones "Mother's Little Helper" - "What a drag it is getting old....."

  13. #13
    Very Active Member knelson's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2003
    Location
    Seattle, WA
    Posts
    7,212
    Blog Entries
    526

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    Quote Originally Posted by hofffam View Post
    In 2004 there was another controversy - the men's 4x100 free. Crocker swam leadoff and swam poorly. He had a fever for several days. He deserved to be on the relay based on time but Eddie misjudged Crocker's ability at the time.
    That relay was more second-guessing than controversy. As you said, Crocker deserved to be on the relay due to his second place finish at Trials. It was sort of a judgement call for Reese whether to keep Ian on the relay even though he wasn't feeling great.

    Picking who swims relays can't be an easy decision for the coaches. There's always going to be someone who felt like they got snubbed. The coaches really need to put blinders on and go with the four people they feel will be the fastest.

  14. #14
    Very Active Member FlyQueen's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    Chicago, IL
    Posts
    1,447
    Blog Entries
    100

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    Quote Originally Posted by lefty View Post
    The men's 800 free relay is going to be really really fast. They are going to go below 7:00 in 5 weeks!

    I am glad that Lochte went ahead and gave the coaches the proof that they need to put him on the relay in Beijing. Clearly he deserves a spot on the relay. He probably would have been on the relay anyhow, but now we won't have a repeat of the minor Phelps/Hall controversy from Athens.

    The 100 back will be great. My bet is the first titan will go down and Piersol doesn't make the team in this event.
    I don't why people keep doubting Peirsol. I'd bet good money he'll have his hand on the wall first. He's been around a long time and knows what he has to do. I think it'll be Peirsol, Bal, Lochte ... we'll see. But Peirsol hits the wall first.
    "I don't race to see who is the fastest, I race to see who has the most guts."

  15. #15
    Very Active Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2002
    Location
    West Bloomfield, MI
    Posts
    1,186

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    Quote Originally Posted by hofffam View Post
    Frank - I thought the controversy in 2004 with the women's 800 involved Rachael Komisarsz? Natalie Coughlin's book describes the controversy but does not name the swimmer who didn't get to swim finals. The book describes a very vocal negative reaction to the coaches decision.

    In 2004 there was another controversy - the men's 4x100 free. Crocker swam leadoff and swam poorly. He had a fever for several days. He deserved to be on the relay based on time but Eddie misjudged Crocker's ability at the time. The relay finished 3rd, unable to recover from the poor 1st leg. Crocker recovered to swim superbly on the medley relay after Phelps stepped aside.
    You are correct with both storys and the one I was refering to was another one in 2000 that was reported on also. The 1996 instance with John Piersma and the 2004 instance with Lindsay Benko was given to prove that even if you win the individual event at Olympic Trials or take second, you are not guaranteed a slot on either the prelims or the finals relays. The 800 Free Relay is a little different than the others because both the Men's and Women's 200 Free individual event is swam with finals before the heats of that relay have swam.

    The 400 Medley Relay heats are swam before the final of the Men's 100 Fly and that is why Michael Phelps swam the prelims of that relay because at the 2004 Olympic Trials he was the second place finisher and thus was selected to swim the morning heats of the 100 Fly. Because he won the individual event over the first place finisher at Olympic Trials (Ian Crocker) he earned the right to swim in the final along with the prelim. This meant that Ian Crocker would not be awarded a medal (gold) in that relay. If he would have swam prelims he would have but no one knew who would win that event until the event was over and that was after the 400 Medley Relay heats. This year there could be the same problem for the coaches to figure.

    This is also the same problem with the 400 Free Relay in that the final is a day before the 100 Free heats for Men and two days before for Women and you are not sure how your top 2 qualifers are going to do. So that relay is usually swam with the 3rd thru 6 place qualifers and they take the top two fastest times from those qualifers. Of course Michael Phelps negated this in 2004 because he posted a :49.05 in winning 2004 spring Nationals and that was a time the coaches wanted the swimmers to beat with Relay take offs factored in for the decision. With the splits it was determined that Neil Walker along with Michael would be joining the top 2 qualifers from the Olympic Trials.

    That sound fair to all of the coaching staff and there was not a controversey until the relay swam and the 2 qualifers the next day failed to make the semi finals for the first time in USA Olympic history. That added fuel to the fire about the non qualifing Phelps, sick Crocker, and a healthy Hall.
    Last edited by Frank Thompson; July 1st, 2008 at 03:44 PM.
    Skip Thompson

  16. #16
    Very Active Member imspoiled's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Philly
    Posts
    486

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    Quote Originally Posted by FlyQueen View Post
    I don't why people keep doubting Peirsol. I'd bet good money he'll have his hand on the wall first. He's been around a long time and knows what he has to do. I think it'll be Peirsol, Bal, Lochte ... we'll see. But Peirsol hits the wall first.
    Heather, you beat me to it! Bal, it seems, has something to prove, so I wouldn't be surprised to see him swim fast again tonight. He doesn't want to be odd man out again. AP is a champion and knows how to get the job done. I really wish everyone would stop dumping on him.
    Twizzlers will be the ruin of Western society... or, at the very least, my waistline.

  17. #17
    Very Active Member scyfreestyler's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2004
    Location
    Kalifornia
    Posts
    3,313

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    Quote Originally Posted by imspoiled View Post
    AP is a champion and knows how to get the job done. I really wish everyone would stop dumping on him.
    Did he also know how to get the job done when Lochte got the 200 back WR?

    Seriously, I think Peirsol is a serious contender and probably favored to win this 100 back showdown, but nobody is infallible.
    I love the smell of neoprene in the morning!

    -Dave Stark

  18. #18
    Very Active Member imspoiled's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Philly
    Posts
    486

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    Quote Originally Posted by scyfreestyler View Post
    Did he also know how to get the job done when Lochte got the 200 back WR?

    Seriously, I think Peirsol is a serious contender and probably favored to win this 100 back showdown, but nobody is infallible.
    Like you've never lost a race, Matt? It happens. Even to Michael Phelps. Yet, it happens to Aaron Peirsol and everyone acts like it's over for him.

    The 100 back final should be one of the best finishes of the trials based on what we've seen so far. No doubt, it will be hundredths of a second that separate the top two from the field. IMO underestimating a gold medalist and WR holder is a bad idea. Yes, he could get beat, but why is everyone acting like it's a foregone conclusion?
    Twizzlers will be the ruin of Western society... or, at the very least, my waistline.

  19. #19
    Very Active Member scyfreestyler's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2004
    Location
    Kalifornia
    Posts
    3,313

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    Quote Originally Posted by imspoiled View Post
    Like you've never lost a race, Matt? It happens. Even to Michael Phelps. Yet, it happens to Aaron Peirsol and everyone acts like it's over for him.

    The 100 back final should be one of the best finishes of the trials based on what we've seen so far. No doubt, it will be hundredths of a second that separate the top two from the field. IMO underestimating a gold medalist and WR holder is a bad idea. Yes, he could get beat, but why is everyone acting like it's a foregone conclusion?

    Trust me, I've lost my share of races.

    Like I said, Peirsol is favored to win in my book...but, I can understand the skepticism that others might have given the events of the past year in Peirsol's signature events.
    I love the smell of neoprene in the morning!

    -Dave Stark

  20. #20
    Very Active Member knelson's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2003
    Location
    Seattle, WA
    Posts
    7,212
    Blog Entries
    526

    Re: Lochte scratches 200 Free

    I predict Peirsol will win in a new world record time. I don't think Bal will be as fast as last night and will end up third or fourth.

    But really it's anyone's guess. Those top four are all very close and I don't really think anyone was holding back yesterday.

Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •